Christian
history has developed two major traditions of reflection upon the Nations
State and the quest for political order. The first is the Augustinian
tradition, which has had major influence upon such diverse groups as the
pro-papal publicists of the 12th and 13th and
centuries and, a far different, Martin Luther, John calvin, and their
modern interpreters like Reinhold Nibuhr.
The other tradition stretches back to Thomas Aquinas, and behind him to
Aristotle and the classical idea of the polis as a res publica.
Thomas influenced Roman Catholic thought upon the state from his own day
down to the present. Especially is this the case if one interprets Aquinas
as moving in the same direction as John of Paris and Marsilius of Padua in
seeking to establish a purely natural basis for the state, independent of
God’s special revelation in Christ.
I plan here to analyze some of the principle ideas in each of these two
traditions, ideas which are by no means always in agreement, and then
apply this to our modern situation and its critical search for a stable
world order.